Saturday, 7 May 2016

Act Four: 'The Naked City,' 'Dragnet' and cops as citizens

 
Welcome to Act Four, culture and politics from Alyssa Rosenberg and everyone at the Act Four blog. Here’s a sample for your immediate enjoyment. If you have been signed up by mistake or you’d rather not receive it, click here to unsubscribe.
 
In shows like "Dragnet" and "The Naked City," cops were citizens of their communities, rather than at war with them.
 
Act Four
Alyssa Rosenberg on culture and politics
 
 
File photo/NBC. Undated. Jack Webb (right) appears as sqeaky-clean Los Angeles police Sgt. Joe Friday in the 1950s television drama 'Dragnet.' His partner, Bill Gannon, was portrayed by Harry Morgan (left). The series portrayed stony detectives who wanted 'just the facts, ma'am' and solved their cases before the last commercial.

Jack Webb (right) appears as sqeaky-clean Los Angeles police Sgt. Joe Friday in the 1950s television drama ‘Dragnet.’ His partner, Bill Gannon, was portrayed by Harry Morgan. The series portrayed stony detectives who wanted ‘just the facts, ma’am’ and solved their cases before the last commercial. (NBC)

I’m working on a long-term project about police shows, movies and novels, and so I’ve been rummaging around in Hollywood’s back catalog and watching a lot of “Dragnet” and “The Naked City” (as well as old Buster Keaton shorts and Keystone Cops stuff). And while there are a lot of threads I’ll be pulling on and writing about, the thing that’s hit me hardest about these early cop shows is this: the extent to which characters like Sgt. Joe Friday (Jack Webb) in “Dragnet” or  Lt. Dan Muldoon (John McIntire) in “The Naked City” were members of their communities rather than at war with them.

Take the pilot episode of “The Naked City,” in which Muldoon and his new partner, Detective Jimmy Halloran (James Franciscus) have to chase down a young Latino immigrant, Arturo Gutierrez (Pat DeSimone), who gets himself involved in a robbery, but turns against the other teenager who recruited him and helps the police to rescue the boy’s hostage.

The show sympathizes with Arturo from the beginning: "Arturo Gutierrez is not a bad boy,” narrator and producer Bert Leonard insists. “He's a poor boy. A hungry boy. Perhaps even an impatient boy. But he's a divided boy, like this morning's breakfast. A quart of milk, divided seven ways." And after the robbery goes wrong and Arturo helps the police, Muldoon, who has been tasked with teaching Halloran how to do detective work, tells Arturo, "I like that, lad. We won't forget it when the time comes." He’s warm, and kind, and invested in the possibility that Arturo can do the right thing.

There’s a similar idea that winds through the early seasons of “Dragnet.” In one episode, Friday and his partner Frank ( Ben Alexander) spend much of their time trying to help a woman who had a child with another man after her husband took a two-year deployment overseas, presumably to fight in the Korean War. There’s no crime at stake, but the cops help the woman through a mental crisis and encourage her husband to be forgiving and accept the child.

In another, a stick-up man who Friday and Frank sent to jail after a shoot-out involving tear gas is paroled on the condition that he accept military service. Before he’s due to be shipped overseas, the man stops by the precinct to visit the cops and to ask them for a few bucks so he can celebrate with his new squadies before he’s shipped out. And, amazingly by today’s standards, they give him the money and celebrate that he seems to be turning around. That the robber turns out to be a bad egg in the end isn’t the point; it’s that Friday and Frank are so optimistic about the prospect of a criminal’s reformation.

It’s a long journey from this to the much more adversarial relationships between citizens and cops that defines both our pop culture and, so often, our headlines, today. That’s a lot of what I’ll be exploring. But looking at where pop culture was is a shocking and immediate barometer for how far it’s traveled in the years since.

ADVERTISEMENT
 
‘Lazaretto’ is a historical novel — and a perfect book for the end of the Obama era
By turning the clock back to the Lincoln administration, Diane McKinney-Whetstone's created a resonant novel for today.
 
In ‘Captain America: Civil War,’ a false choice between Iron Man and Captain America
Marvel is amping up the conflict between two of its franchise characters in 'Civil War.' But what if they're both right?
 
‘Crazy Rich Asians,’ ‘The Best Man,’ and the power of the romantic comedy franchise
At a time when romantic comedies are marginalized and good roles for actors of color are rare, rom-com franchises are a rare, and delightful, exception.
 
What ‘Captain America: Civil War’ and ‘Batman v. Superman’ have in common
In conquering the world, superhero movies are losing their ability to be intellectually ambitious, even as they still crave social significance.
 
Covering Donald Trump as a cultural figure made it easier to take him seriously
Donald Trump's longtime media prominence and his skill at exploiting existing cultural scripts made him seem like a more plausible candidate than establishment political wisdom suggested.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Recommended for you
 
Intersect
The corner of the Internet and interesting, in your inbox weekly.
Sign Up »
 
     
 
©2016 The Washington Post, 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment