Friday 26 August 2016

Fact Checker: Unraveling the alleged (and nonexistent) tie between Huma Abedin and the Muslim Brotherhood

Unraveling the alleged (and nonexistent) tie between Huma Abedin and the Muslim Brotherhood At The Fact Checker, we always say the best fact-checks are like detective work, where you trace the origin of talking points and who said what in the ensuing game of telephone. We unraveled a claim this week that was like mapping out …
 
Fact Checker
The truth behind the rhetoric
 
 

Unraveling the alleged (and nonexistent) tie between Huma Abedin and the Muslim Brotherhood

At The Fact Checker, we always say the best fact-checks are like detective work, where you trace the origin of talking points and who said what in the ensuing game of telephone.

We unraveled a claim this week that was like mapping out a case of six degrees of separation: Allegations that Huma Abedin, longtime Clinton aide, has ties to the Muslim Brotherhood and was editor of a “Sharia newspaper.” Our extensive fact-check has all the details, so check it out here. The summary below will give you an idea of the flimsy body of evidence.

Abedin is associated with a peer-reviewed academic journal exploring the rights of minority Muslims, edited by her mother and founded by her late father. (It’s not a “Sharia newspaper.”)

In 1978, Abedin’s father founded a think tank that published the journal. The think tank had the support of Abdullah Omar Naseef, then-president of a university. Naseef later became secretary-general of the Muslim World League, a pan-Islamic nongovernmental organization. In that role, in 1988, Naseef authorized a Pakistani charity which, years later, became associated with al-Qaeda.

Meanwhile, Abedin’s mother founded a women and children’s aid organization, which at one point was said to be affiliated with  International Islamic Council for Da'wa and Relief, which years later was banned in Israel for allegedly supporting Hamas, a Palestinian offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood.

The allegations are based in vague suggestions of suspicious-sounding connections to her parents that don't pass the laugh test. We awarded Four Pinocchios.

(Courtesy of giphy.com)

(Courtesy of giphy.com)

Enjoy this newsletter? Forward it to someone else who'd like it! If this e-mail was forwarded to you, sign up here for the weekly newsletter. Hear something fact-checkable? Send it here, we’ll check it out. 

Kudos to Trump for adjusting his talking points! 

Could it be the Kellyanne Conway effect? This week, we wrote about two problematic claims by Trump — and the talking points were changed the next day. So maybe the credit goes to Trump’s new campaign manager.

Trump frequently says “58 percent of black youth are unemployed.” But the official Bureau of Labor Statistics unemployment rate for black youth is 19.2 percent — about one-third of Trump’s figure. Trump’s rate includes students, who are not working and not looking for a job. The BLS definition for “unemployed” — which is internationally accepted — refers to people who are available for work and actively looking for a job, but don’t have one. We awarded Four Pinocchios to his claim.

ADVERTISEMENT
 

After our fact-check published, Trump stopped using the term “unemployed.” He changed it to: “58 percent of African American youth are not working.” (That’s still a bit misleading, but less than “unemployed.”)

There was a lot of buzz over an AP story this week, which was mischaracterized by Trump and even the AP’s own promotional tweet. The AP found that 85 of 154 non-governmental people who met with Clinton as secretary of state were donors to the Clinton Foundation. The 154 figure is a small portion of the overall number of people Clinton met with during her tenure (upwards of 2,000 people) and based on partial data (first half of her tenure).

But Trump instead said: “50 percent of the people that saw her had to make contributions to the Clinton Foundation.” That’s not correct. After we wrote about it, Trump corrected his talking point. He said: “As the Associated Press documented, more than half of the meetings Hillary Clinton took as Secretary of State with people outside government were Clinton Foundation donors.”

(Courtesy of giphy.com)

(Courtesy of giphy.com)

Happy #FactCheckFriday!

On #FactCheckFriday, we flood social media with our latest work. Check us out on Twitter at @myhlee and @GlennKesslerWP, Facebook Live at facebook.com/washingtonpost, and Snapchat at ‘washingtonpost.’ Send us your fact-check submissions to #FactCheckThis. Check out our Twitter Moments round-up of the week in fact-checking.

We’re always looking for fact-check suggestions: fill out this form, e-mail us, tweet us directly, or use #FactCheckThis. Read about our rating scale here, and sign up here for our weekly Fact Checker newsletter. 

Scroll down for this week’s Pinocchio round-up.

–Michelle Ye Hee Lee

 
Trump’s false claim that undocumented immigrants collect Social Security benefits
Trump makes a bizarre claim about Social Security benefits for undocumented immigrants, but it's unsupported by facts.
 
Does Huma Abedin have ‘ties’ to the Muslim Brotherhood?
Vague suggestions of suspicious-sounding connections to the parents of the Clinton aide don't pass the laugh test.
 
Trump’s misleading claim that 58 percent of black youths are unemployed
Trump uses his own measure of black youth unemployment that blows the figure way out of proportion and inaccurately reflects the labor market.
 
Clinton’s misleading citation of ’15 million jobs’ under Obama
Clinton loves to say Obama created 15 million jobs. But that's 5 million jobs too high.
 
 
Pro-Clinton group takes a Donald Trump quote out of context
With such great material for attack ads, why would a pro-Clinton group feel the need to push the envelope?
 
How many Trump products were made overseas? Here’s the complete list.
We take an inventory of all the countries where Trump products were made.
 
Here’s how Trump got the AP story on Clinton Foundation donors all wrong
Trump misrepresents Clinton Foundation donors' meetings with Clinton as secretary of state, based on flawed social media reports.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Recommended for you
 
The Daily Trail
An evening rundown of what's happening on the campaign trail.
Sign Up »
 
     
 
©2016 The Washington Post, 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment